If you’ve been anywhere near fitness TikTok or Instagram lately, you’ll know there’s a big conversation going on about Pilates. It’s no longer just a mat in your living room — reformer studios are popping up everywhere, and the “Pilates princess” trend is all over social media. But how does Pilates actually stack up against traditional resistance training when it comes to real, practical results?
At our Leeds studio, this is something clients ask us about all the time. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide what’s right for you.
What Pilates Does Really Well
Pilates is all about controlled movement, posture, and building strength from the inside out. Research shows it can be especially powerful for:
-
Core and trunk strength – think stability, balance, and a stronger lower back.
-
Flexibility and mobility – improving joint health and range of motion.
-
Posture and alignment – reducing aches and pains from desk jobs and modern life.
-
Mind–body benefits – many studies link Pilates to better body awareness, reduced anxiety, and improved overall wellbeing.
In short: Pilates is brilliant if you want to move better, feel more connected to your body, and improve functional strength that carries over into everyday life.
Where Resistance Training Wins
Resistance training (lifting weights, using machines, resistance bands) works on progressive overload — gradually adding more challenge over time. That makes it incredibly effective for:
-
Building muscle mass and definition
-
Improving bone density and joint strength (key for long-term health, especially as we age)
-
Boosting metabolism – more muscle means you burn more calories at rest
-
Maximising strength gains – especially in larger muscle groups
If your primary goal is to get stronger, change your body composition, or future-proof your bones, resistance training is hard to beat.
What the Science Says
Recent studies comparing Pilates and resistance training show:
-
Strength: Resistance training usually produces bigger gains in overall muscle strength and endurance.
-
Flexibility & Core: Pilates often wins for flexibility, trunk stability, and posture.
-
Body composition: Reformer Pilates can improve body fat percentage and muscle tone, especially in beginners or people returning to exercise.
-
Wellbeing: Pilates tends to score higher for reducing stress and boosting mental health.
So, it’s not really about which is “better” — it’s about which suits your goals.
Our Take: Why Not Both?
At our Leeds studio, we see the best results when clients combine the two. Here’s why:
-
Pilates gives you the alignment, core stability, and mobility to lift better and stay injury-free.
-
Resistance training adds the raw strength, muscle, and bone health benefits that Pilates alone may not provide.
Together, they create a well-rounded programme that supports health, performance, and confidence in your body.
If you’re deciding between Pilates and resistance training, ask yourself what you’re really aiming for. Do you want better posture, less pain, and more mobility? Pilates could be your best starting point. Want to get stronger, build muscle, or reshape your body? Resistance training is key.
And if you want the full package? Combine both — that’s where the magic happens.
At our Leeds studio, we offer tailored programmes that blend resistance training with Pilates-inspired movement. Whether you’re new to exercise or looking to level up, we’ll help you get results that last.